Recharge vs Bold vs Recurpay: Which Shopify Subscription App is best?

Main differences between Recharge vs BOLD subscriptions?

Bold provides a wide range of 14+ apps on Shopify, covering everything from basic subscriptions to loyalty programs, upselling and B2B.

Recharge, on the other hand, focuses on a single and robust solution for subscriptions, packed with all the essential features. They focus only on subscriptions which allows them to solve subscription specific use cases and move faster in subscription market.

So if you are building a business exclusively for subscriptions then Recharge is comparatively better.

In comparison Recurpay also solely focus on subscriptions and is quite popular for providing the best subscription portal for customers where they can manage the entire subscriptions and the merchants have the flexibility to offer tiered discounting, product upsell right on the subscription portal. Recurpay has migrated 350+ merchants from Recharge and Bold.

Recharge

Recharge is a subscription app designed to help ecommerce businesses easily set up and manage recurring payments. It’s particularly popular among Shopify merchants. With Recharge, businesses can create flexible subscription models, handle customer relationships, and scale their subscription-based offerings. The app integrates smoothly with Shopify, making it a go-to solution for merchants looking to add subscription services in their online stores.

Bold

Bold is one of the earliest app partners of Shopify. Their subscription app enables businesses to set up recurring orders, process automatic payments, and simplify the entire subscription experience for customers.

Bold is designed to offer a wide range of other apps, including upselling and cross-selling, making it a versatile tool for online businesses. Bold also includes helpful features like subscription bundles, discounts on subscriptions, and integrated payment gateways that make the checkout process smoother for customers.

‍

Feature Comparison
‍

Subscription Options and Widget:

Both Recharge and Bold allows you to offer subscription options on the product page of your shopify store. You can select between multiple range of widget designs which suits your brand. Although while getting started with Bold and Recharge it might require you to get in touch with your development team as you would require technical skills to set it up in the right way.

In comparison Recurpay offers a DIY subscription widget which can be setup the moment you install the app and won't require any technical skills to get started. You can also translate the widget and customise the color as per your brand.

Getting Started and Ease of Use:

If you're not very tech-savvy and want to set up subscriptions on your store, getting started with Recharge or Bold might take a bit longer than you'd expect. These apps are primarily geared towards larger businesses, and they don't offer a guided tour to help you get going.

On the other hand Recurpay provides a smooth onboarding experience, complete with a helpful tour that guides you through setting up subscriptions. With Recurpay, you can have subscriptions up and running on your store in just a few minutes, making the process easy and stress-free.

Analytics:

Analytics are essential for any business. Without data to guide your decisions, how can you determine the best direction for your business or measure the success of your campaigns?  

Both Bold and Recharge offer powerful analytics for subscription products, enabling you to make informed decisions and drive your business forward. Recharge is a bit superior in terms of offering robust analytics on customer cohorts, cohort retention, subscription KPI’s and industry benchmarking.

Native Cart and Account Upsell:

Recharge and Bold doesn't offer a direct way to upsell subscriptions on cart although you can definitely get that added with the help of your development team

Recurpay allows you to enable cart and account upsell with just a few clicks on your Shopify store.

Pricing Comparison
‍

Recharge:

Recharge offers 2 pricing plans:

$99 per month + 1.25% + 19¢ on all subscription orders.

$499 per month + 1% + 19¢ on all subscription orders.

Bold:

Bold Subscriptions has a CORE plan:

$49.99 per month + 1% additional transaction fee on all subscription orders.

Recurpay:

Pricing for Recurpay works in a pay as you go model with no annual contracts and starts from just $9 per month.

Support Comparison

To get more information in terms of support we have checked out the reviews for both Bold and Recharge

Recharge

Recharge currently holds an aggregate rating of 4.5 on the Shopify App Store. However, a recent price increase has sparked considerable dissatisfaction, leading to a noticeable drop in their ratings.

Bold

Bold has an aggregate rating of 4.3 on the Shopify App Store. Recently, their ratings have seen a significant decline, particularly regarding customer support and product issues.

Recurpay

Recurpay boasts an impressive aggregate rating of 4.9 on the Shopify App Store, with 90% of reviews specifically praising their exceptional customer support.

Conclusion

ReCharge excels in features, technical capabilities, and analytics, making it a leading choice for subscription management. However, its high pricing and subpar post-sales support may be a downside.

Recurpay, on the other hand, is a fantastic alternative, providing all the essential subscription features, including native cart and account upsell, with no annual contracts and at a lower price than Recharge. This affordability and robust functionality make Recurpay a top pick for merchants looking for a reliable subscription app on Shopify. Recurpay also offers a free white glove migration from both Recharge and Bold subscriptions.